"The clearest impact for us has been on average order value and incremental revenue per sale... we saw a lift."

In the words of Adam Schneider, Victrola’s VP of Enterprise System, the brand is on its journey to make some very modern ecommerce move. And the interesting part is, other than being the most iconic label in the world of record players and hi-fi audio, the brand is also 120-years old.

I know most of you mentally checked out right after reading “we saw a lift” and immediately started wondering what actually worked for the brand. So let’s skip ahead with one simple question:

‍
How can a brand that sells turntables with a price range of around $1,500, technical intimidation factors, and attract only passionate buyers- increase their AOV and attach rate?

Yes, you can run the usual playbook. Build bundles. Optimize cross-sells. Set your free shipping threshold just above AOV. Turn on BNPL. But if you’ve been in ecommerce long enough, you’ve probably already done most of it. And on the product side, squeezing harder usually leads to smaller and smaller gains.  

However, there’s one thing you might not have considered yet: selling something you never have to ship.

That being said, this is how Victrola did it and this is what other specialty brands can learn from the same playbook.

Victrola didn’t achieve it by selling more turntables

First, some context.  

Victrola isn't a startup testing growth hacks. This is a brand that's been around since 1906, went dormant in the late '70s, and came back in the early 2010s riding the vinyl resurgence. They also own KLH Audio, a legacy hi-fi speaker brand. They curate over 2,000 records on their site and collaborate with names like Netflix (Stranger Things) and Third Man Records.

In Adam's words to our team- "We're a music brand, not just a hardware brand. We live and breathe music."

So, they needed a strategy that didn’t seem salesy but felt like part of the culture, part of a culture their customers felt accustomed to.

And that came through with SureBright’s extended and accidental warranties.

What Victrola did

The brand had been exploring extended warranties for two to three years before pulling the trigger. The holdup was all about finding a partner that wouldn't force a generic widget onto their product pages. And every provider they evaluated wanted to drop in a plug-and-play install that looked like it belonged to a different site.

That’s when SureBright entered the scene.

“What ultimately won me over was the technology... SureBright had a good UI, and crucially they weren't just an app plugin. That meant we could customize and partner on the implementation rather than accept a one-size-fits-all install.”

Victrola placed protection plans on the product page, in a pop-up if the customer hadn't added the warranty, and once more at final checkout. That's it. Three touchpoints, that showed they cared for their customers.

And what was the result?

Immediate, consistent AOV lift from the moment they activated.

“We've seen a clear lift in average order value since activation. We're also seeing record D2C sales overall right now, driven by a number of factors... With record volume comes more opportunities to attach the warranty, so AOV growth and revenue from SureBright have moved together.”

Every ecommerce brand wants this in a board meeting. Very few get it without operational chaos attached.

And Victrola is a textbook example of how to do it right.

In other words, when someone's spending $1,500 on, let’s say, a Stream Sapphire turntable, the option to protect that investment doesn't just bring in additional revenue; it also removes a reason not to buy- and thus subtly increased the conversion rates.

Other brands who did the same thing

Victrola's story is clean, but it's not an outlier.

E-bike retailers like Magnum Bikes, Levy Electric, and Go Power Bike were stuck in the same spot: thin margins, fierce competition, products that cost thousands but come with manufacturer warranties that only cover 12 to 24 months. They added protection plans through SureBright and hit a 20.2% average attach rate, spiking to 38% on peak days. Net profit jumped 14.4% & conversions lifted 18%.

Lawn and garden equipment sellers like SuperHandy and Great Circle saw attach rates climb past 50% on their highest-ticket products like ride-on mowers. Their product ratings went from 4.1 to 4.7 in four months.

And that’s not all, specialty grill retailers grew profit margins by 16% and finally had an answer for competing against big-box stores that had been offering protection for years.

It's not just these. Here's the pattern across specialty verticals.

Turns out the playbook works just as well whether you’re selling vinyl nostalgia or a $3,000 lawn machine.

What’s the playbook here for your brand?

If you're reading this far, to tell you the truth, you're not looking for "add a warranty" as advice. You're looking for the framework. Here it is -

• Every traditional AOV play fights for the same dollars: Add another product, bundle another accessory, squeeze one more item into the cart. Service revenue doesn’t compete for shelf space, warehouse space, or margin. It simply layers on top. No inventory. No fulfillment. No race-to-the-bottom discounting. Just incremental revenue stacking onto the order.

• High ticket multiplied by low frequency is your ideal setup. A protection plan on a $30 phone case is noise. A protection plan on a $1,500 turntable, a $2,000 e-bike, or a $3,000 ride-on mower is a meaningful number. And the buyer of that product already has purchase anxiety, the protection option directly addresses those fears.

• Integration quality matters more than you think: If your dev team can't customize the display, the placement, and the flow, the provider is wrong. The warranty experience IS your brand experience. If it looks like a generic widget, it's actively hurting you.

• Start before you think you're ready. The AOV lift is immediate. The long-term data on loyalty and claims comes soon after. Waiting for perfect conditions means waiting while your competitors stack margin.

So, how are you closing it?

Every brand in this piece ran the same experiment and the results weren't theoretical... they showed up in the next month's numbers.

SureBright is the partner behind all of them. Ten-minute setup. Zero upfront cost. Your dev team stays in control of how it looks and where it lives. And if Adam Schneider, a guy who's been in tech for nearly 20 years and openly hates aggressive warranty prompts, recommends Victrola’s technical team, that's worth something.

If your checkout is already optimized and you're looking for the next lever, this is probably it. So schedule your demo today.