Your attribution dashboard is lying to you.
Not on purpose though, but it’s just trying to measure a world where clicks barely exist.
Late in 2024, HubSpot lost nearly 80% of its blog traffic after Google’s updates. For most brands, that would’ve been fatal. But HubSpot survived because they’d already cut 30,000+ low-value pages and doubled down on channels they could control; newsletters, YouTube, podcasts, creators.
So, Traffic is fragile. Trust and demand are what last.
The numbers tell the story:
So, what does this really mean for merchants?
Sure, fewer clicks can feel like lost traffic, but it doesn’t have to mean lost opportunity.
Because in a zero-click world, visibility could be just as valuable as a visit. Showing up in SERPs, TikTok feeds, or Pinterest boards still shapes buying decisions, even when the click never comes.
The challenge now is simple: learn how to turn that visibility into growth, even when attribution hides the proof. Let’s take a look at why attribution is broken and how you can still win in a zero-click world by adapting to changes.
First let’s understand,
Attribution didn’t collapse because GA4 has bugs. It collapsed because the internet no longer plays by the same rules, and the platforms rewrote those rules.
For years, merchants lived by a clean model: see ad → click → convert. Today, that model was dismantled piece by piece. Here’s how.
Platforms hoard traffic → Google answers queries on the SERP (AI Overviews cut clicks by 34.5%), and nearly 30% of clicks stay on Google-owned properties. Social platforms do the same:
👉 The new game isn’t clicks; it’s containment.
Dark social hides discovery → 84% of content shares happen in WhatsApp, Slack, Instagram DMs and Discord. GA4 calls it “Direct,” but it’s really untrackable referrals. Attribution trails vanish even as brand mentions rise.
Privacy walls are rising → Apple’s ATT alone wiped out $10B in Meta’s ad revenue. Add in 42% of users running ad blockers, and the ability to connect touchpoints is disappearing fast.
The open web is shrinking → In 2023, millions of small/mid sites lost 3.2% of traffic to 170 giants. Those giants barely share back, only 0.103% referral growth.
👉 Even winning in the SERP may not move the needle.
The merchants winning today aren’t chasing clicks, they’re building visibility where buyers already spend their time. The strategy is no longer “rank and convert,” it’s “show up, staying top of mind, and turn visibility into demand.
If Google is giving you less, don’t walk away. Search is still the world’s biggest discovery engine. But don’t make it your only bet. The smartest retailers don’t try to be everywhere at once. They test widely, learn fast, and then double down on the one or two channels that truly drive profitable growth.
We break down how it works here: Bullseye framework: How smart retailers find profitable marketing
Remember: Google doesn’t own your audience. You do. The more you spread discovery across channels, the less one algorithm can choke your growth.
If Google is hoarding clicks, sometimes you have to pay to stay visible. It's not the ideal answer, but it's still an effective one. When you get some visibility for a better option, definitely opt for that.
Don’t see PPC as buying clicks. See it as buying shelf space in a world where Google rents the aisles.
Stop thinking “blog → click.” Start thinking “content → memory.”
Value delivered in-feed builds trust long before a buyer ever types your URL.
Your products can show up even when your site doesn’t.
These “free listings” place you directly in Shopping, Images, Maps, and Lens, without a single click to your site.
Shoppers don’t just research in text anymore. They watch and pin/save
Visual search = zero-click influence that builds memory.
Google is answering questions before anyone clicks. That means your brand needs to be the answer.
If you’re not showing up in these features, you’re invisible, even if you rank.
Zero-click drives awareness. Retention monetizes it.
The merchants who thrive won’t just create impressions. They’ll turn recognition into repeat revenue.
If clicks don’t tell the whole story, these signals will:
If you’re focused on improving margins, not just chasing more sales, extended warranties can be a high-margin lever, we as SureBright can help you.
Our AI-powered product protection doesn’t just bolt onto your store. It gives you a full picture of attach rates, AOV impact, and conversion lift tied directly to warranty placement and behavior. It helps you to connect the dots between warranty metrics and retail metrics.
We’ve broken this down in detail here: Warranty Metrics Here? Retail KPIs There? Get a 360° View Through Interconnected Metric Lens
Finally,
The reality is clear: attribution isn’t broken by accident; it’s broken by design. Platforms make more when users stay inside their walls, and merchants are left staring at dashboards that don’t match reality.
Clicks still matter and they drive transactions. But they’re no longer the whole story. Impressions, branded demand, and retention now carry as much weight as last click reports.
The merchants who thrive in 2025 will be the ones who balance both: capturing clicks where possible, while also measuring the unseen influence that builds demand and trust.
And while the funnel is getting a bit harder to track, the post-purchase experience is still yours to control.
With SureBright, you can build the kind of trust that keeps customers coming back, not just at checkout, but long after. Let us help you build trust.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
