Sitting out this Cyber week? Here's what you can do to prepare your store for next season

Summary
Skipping Cyber Week can be a smart call, but only if you use the time well. This guide shows merchants how to protect their margins and test every order path before next season’s rush, so the store you reopen is better prepared.
Overview of Contents
In a 2025 Xero survey of small business owners, 72% said discounts had been the most effective sales tactic during the past holiday sales seasons. Yet 34% never run a holiday promotion at all (likely because they already offered their best rates). So if you are a retailer who’s sitting out this Cyber Week, you are in good company.
A few years back, REI made a similar decision which, despite earlier confusion, turned out to be a stroke of genius. The American retailer closed its physical stores and gave its employees Black Friday off with pay. The move drew 1.4 million social media hits, while its web sales spiked 26% over the Black Friday holiday weekend.
But given REI’s scale, it could afford a stunt like that. For most merchants, the decision to skip the Cyber Week rush comes down to what it costs them, as this merchant explained so well:
“I’ve done it for the last 2 years, both times were a massive headache and not worth it. Lost money both times. Customers demanded discounts because they missed the promo windows, etc. and with the cost of fuel and tariffs, we can’t afford it.”
Like this merchant, you may have your own reasons for sitting out this season. But skipping the week only spares you this season’s headaches, while doing nothing for your next season. And a store that doesn’t utilize this period will again walk into the next quarter with the same thin margins and the same crowded field.
That’s why we have curated this guide, so when the calendar turns again- you can confidently open the second act with a store that is better prepared for the holiday rush.
Pick the profit first and let the sales follow
Last year’s Cyber Week generated more than $44 billion in online sales, up 7.7% from 2024. Discounts helped drive that spending, with Cyber Monday markdowns reaching 31% off in electronics and 19% off in furniture.
This year, the National Retail Federation expects November and December sales to reach $1.013 trillion, up 4.2%. With that kind of business opportunity at stake, discounts are likely to deepen too. And the higher the discount, the lower the margin.
One merchant who quit chasing markdowns saw how low his margins had been while discounting:
“In October, I finally decided to stop running constant promotions and keep my products at their regular prices. As expected, my order volume dropped, but here’s the interesting part: the higher profit per order has been compensating for the lower number of orders. So, despite receiving fewer orders, I’m not necessarily making less money.”

So instead of competing on discounts, you need to sit down and decide how much profit a sale must bring you for it to be really worthwhile. That number becomes your anchor in the discount wars, because it also tells you how much cost a sale can bear.
Give each product its own floor margin too. As this will help you identify whether a bulky item whose freight and damage costs swallow a discount, should stay in the catalog at full price or it should simply sit out the sitewide sale.
Once you have decided on the end goal, you have to identify the hero who will lead you to it.
Not every product earns a second season
Most Cyber Week guides rank products by how many left the warehouse. However they say nothing about how many came back or broke, or how many landed in your support inbox in February.
That is why a product should earn its place in your holiday sale catalog based on its full lifecycle, not just its sales rank. One merchant learned this the hard way (and no, it’s not as uncommon as you’d think):
“I did $1.55M in sales on newly launched brand. Profit? Negative. The reason: poor product quality pushed returns above 18%, and margins never recovered.”
If you don’t want to be in this merchant’s shoes, give every SKU a scorecard that tracks its contribution margin, return, damage and exchange rates, support tickets, warranty claims, reverse freight, refurbishment cost and inventory aging. Use those numbers to decide what deserves more investment and what doesn’t.
- Promote products that sell consistently, protect your margins and almost never cause problems after delivery, like ceramic mugs that sell every week and arrive without a chip.
- Fix products that have strong demand but lose money through damaged packaging, frequent exchanges or unreliable suppliers. A glass lamp shoppers love is worth saving if one in eight arrives cracked, because better packaging solves the problem.
- Drop or restrict products that keep generating losses through returns, damage, service costs or constant markdowns, even after you’ve tried to fix them. An office chair that still comes back with wobbly legs after a supplier switch has had its chance.
That rigorous effort will give you a catalog that does not hide a bestseller eating cash through returns, replacements and support. It also frees the promotion calendar for products with better lifetime economics than last year’s list.
Still, even the most carefully selected products have to meet customers’ delivery expectations.
A carrier’s last shipping date is not a delivery date
“A buyer messaged me earlier saying her order arrived late (the day after Christmas) and demands that I refund her for shipping. My processing time is set to 3–5 business days, with weekends blocked off, and I shipped the order on time on the 18th, which was the deadline for Priority Mail. When I dropped it off at the post office, the estimated delivery date was set for December 23rd.”

The seller’s mistake was treating the carrier’s last shipping date as a delivery guarantee. To avoid the same problem, plan backward from the date the customer needs the order. Count back through carrier pickup, warehouse cutoff, fraud review, picking and packing to find your actual order deadline.
That deadline should leave some margin for Murphy's law. USPS lists December 18 for Priority Mail this year but sheepishly also highlights that actual delivery may vary. UPS also warns that some Ground packages may need extra transit time through January 8. So when timing is critical for your customers, you need to set your own order cutoff earlier than either carrier’s date.
Once you have a realistic cutoff, show the expected delivery date on product pages. With 64% of consumers likely to do most of their holiday shopping over Thanksgiving weekend, a clear date helps them decide whether your offer will arrive in time.
Even with that planning, some orders will arrive late or damaged. Decide in advance how quickly customers will be contacted and what remedy, such as a shipping refund, they can expect.
Whatever you offer, someone has to pay to deliver it, and nothing hides that bill like the word free.
Fix what you can and protect against what you can’t
When France banned free book shipping in 2014, Amazon started charging one cent. It was a token fee, barely changing what customers paid, but it let Amazon preserve what shoppers had come to expect, which was practically free shipping on books.
More than a decade later, that expectation hasn’t gone away. Kenco’s 2026 survey found that 73% of North American shoppers expect free shipping as baseline, while 47% expect free returns. But don’t give in to those demands without thought, as parents do to stop a crying child. It might cost you a fortune, as this seller experienced:
“I sell small-ticket stuff online, not huge volume. Outbound shipping I have under control. Returns are the part that is eating me. Last month two customers sent items back and the return label cost almost as much as I made on the order.”
Before setting your shipping terms, count base rates, fuel, residential fees, packaging, labor and the second box a large basket might need. Peak season adds to the bill, with surcharges of $0.75 per package at UPS and $0.80 at FedEx from around November 22 through December 27.
Shipping into Canada needs its own calculation. Since September 8, certain U.S.-origin goods have faced surtaxes of 15%, 25% or 50%.
However, all the preparation on paper is only a theory until a real order tests it.

Run the whole show once before opening night
A Shopify seller described their Black Friday morning in a Reddit post:
“i password protected my shop last night bc i needed to finish some last minute details this morning…and now i can’t even make any of the changes or even make my site live🥲 been up since 7am PST and still no updates from Shopify”

You don't want to discover a problem with your store when customers are already trying to place orders.
That’s why you need to run the entire order process before next Cyber Week or any holiday season sale, for that matter. Place real test orders on a phone and a desktop, then follow each one from confirmation through inventory updates and fulfillment to carrier handoff. Test what happens when a customer returns an item or files a warranty claim, too. A failed payment or a low-stock item can expose problems that a routine order won't.
Try a backorder and a Canadian delivery address as well. Once the process works, freeze platform changes before peak season so the setup you tested is the one customers actually use.
But you also need to see how your setup works with AI shopping assistants. A Blue Yonder survey found that nearly a quarter of U.S. shoppers had bought on an AI recommendation, and 46% of them returned one, with 36% saying it differed from its description. That makes the product page part of the test, not just the checkout.
When a test exposes a failure, assign someone to deal with it and decide what happens next. For example, if a carrier misses a pickup, someone should know who contacts the customer and who can approve a replacement or refund. Finding that gap now is far cheaper than figuring it out after an order goes wrong.
What the quiet weeks are good for
Sitting out Cyber Week gives you something the busiest merchants may not have until January, which is time. Use it to identify the issues eating into your margins. You can fix many of them, but you can’t prevent every product breakdown or accidental damage.

SureBright takes that claims work off your team’s plate. When a customer files a claim, we handle the repair or replacement, while you continue earning revenue on every plan sold. Sennheiser, for example, achieved attach rates of 28% to 31% with SureBright while reducing category returns by 26% year over year.
Before the next season starts, see what protection plans could add to your bottom line with SureBright’s warranty revenue calculator.

Author
Pushpender Singh
Pushpender enjoys exploring the stories behind everyday decisions. He writes about warranties, ecommerce, and the psychology of buying. He draws on internet research, lively conversations, and a curiosity for the details most people overlook. With a background in English Literature, he believes good writing isn't measured by how complex it sounds, but by how effortlessly it helps someone understand a complex idea. Outside of work, you'll usually find him reading fiction and history, striking up conversations with people from different walks of life, or jotting down ideas inspired by both.
How much money can warranties add to your business?
45 seconds, 6 questions, one eye-opening answer.


